From reading chapter two in Hick’s text “Crafting Digital Writing", I have gained insight of knowing the different elements in author’s craft. As a reader, I usually recognize elements when I read traditional texts. For instance, I begin focusing on the story elements including figuring out the characters, setting, problem, solution, and any other figurative language. I found that looking for the elements makes it easier for a reader to make meaning of a text. When students do not have the ability to find the elements that the author includes, they begin to struggle with reading the text.
I believe that students should be introduced to both traditional and digital texts in the classroom during reading instruction. Also, students should learn all the elements included in author’s craft to help make meaning of multiple texts. For myself, I think it is harder to teach and talk about utilizing digital texts in the classroom because most students in the class do not always have access to technology at school. It all depends within the financial income of the school district. Therefore, I believe that all classrooms should incorporate digital texts while students are learning about different genres. However, it is easier to find the audience and figure out what voices are made.
Also, learning about the crafting visuals is fascinating because it includes features such as movement, contrast, color, tone, and background that attracts the reader. Therefore, I will encourage my students to use color, background and movement when creating digital texts independently or with their peers. Furthermore, I think it is difficult to teach all the elements including words, images, sounds, and videos, in order for the students to become creative. Some students may have more experienced than others with using technology. However if I taught students on how to create digital texts, I believe students would enjoy reading more and they would have responsibility and ownership of their learning.
Another component that I would struggle as a teacher would be to teach students to combine several sources and explore different texts on the computer. With doing this, the students would need to make sure that the sources are accurate and up to date. If I taught them on how to combine several sources to present an argument, I believe my students would attempt it.
I have many strengths and weaknesses when it comes to writing. As a student, I found that the most challenging element for myself in college was making a claim and finding the correct evidence in a passage to prove an argument. I struggled with finding correct reasoning to back up my evidence. I tend to make a claim, and then it goes downhill from there. As a graduate student, I am currently working on making claims from reading different passages that I can argue to my audience without hesitation. The aspects that are the most challenging when I write would be explaining quotations and trying to figure out what the author is conveying. Sometimes, I struggle with understanding what a quote means while trying to put it in my own words. Therefore, I usually re-read the passage or sentence to gain more clarity. For every text I read, in order to understand the passage, I usually write important ideas in the margins that the author includes. My weakness is that I tend to move off track and speak about something that has nothing to do with the quote I am trying to analyze.
Another element that is difficult would be word choice in essays. Speaking of my personal writing experiences, I struggle with choosing the correct word I want to use in a sentence. At times, I feel like I am using the correct word. Then other times, I feel overwhelmed because I know what I am trying to say verbally, but then I am unable to transition it to the paper. As a writer, I am currently working on making sure my sentences make sense and that my sentences flow nicely.
Speaking of my student teaching experiences, I have used many of the elements of writer’s craft that Tompkin used. For example, I do focus on almost all of the six traits when I write an essay. For instance, I focus most of my time on organization, voice, ideas and presentation to make my writing more enjoyable for my audience to read. When I start my introduction, I try to grab the reader’s attention and hold interest in them. Usually when I write about something I care and is passionate about, I tend to make my writing better because I always have more ideas to write about and feel free to express all my feelings. In addition, my strength is poetry. I love writing poems because I have the opportunity to become creative as well as having the control to play with the words.
While reading chapters in both Hicks and Tompkins, I realize that the elements in author’s craft are key to reading and writing. When I become a teacher, I now realize that I should teach my students how to play with the words they write. If I model in front of my students, then they might want to write more, and the activity will become more engaging. Also, when they have the chance to play with words, they can interact with their peers to notice if their classmates wrote different words than them.
Another element I would focus on in my classroom will be finding the main idea and details in a passage. For reading, I will encourage my students to find the main idea and three details that supports their argument. When students understand on how to find the main idea and details, reading becomes much easier for them, especially if they are able to comprehend. In my student teaching placement, many of the students I worked with had difficulty finding the main idea and details while reading a passage. Therefore, I provided them with some instructional strategies that would benefit and support their reading. I found that when students use strategies, they are able to improve their reading comprehension skills.
To meet this end, I will push myself to follow the six traits while I am introduced to a new writing prompt or text. Also, I will work on word choice in my essays and double check to make sure my sentences make sense. In addition, I will work on using correct evidence and claims while writing an argumentative essay. Lastly, I plan to teach my students the “heart of writing”. This includes getting their ideas down on paper in order to make their writing delightful for the audience to read.
I am excited to teach the six traits that I learned from Tompkins and Hicks in my classroom someday.
References
Tompkins, G. E. (2019). Teaching writing: Balancing process and product (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill.
Hicks, T. (2013). Crafting digital writing. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Anna, you provide some interesting "broad stroke" statements about students and what they need time to understand and practice when it comes to thinking about teaching the traits of a composition. I am left wondering though, when you talk about teaching students, who exactly are these students you have in mind? If you were design lessons for second grader readers and writers on how to write an essay, what specifically would you want to focus on? How might you need to modify the suggestions offered by Hicks and Tompkins? What would be your greatest concerns? "Imagining" or focusing your thinking for a specific group of students as your write these entries will allow you to get into the intricacies of the topic.
ReplyDelete